15 April 2008 ~ View Comments

Sisters.

I have a confession to make.

My sisters aren’t speaking to me.

My oldest sister says that I am too “scary”. My next older sister is in a mental institution. My little sister tells me I am “selfish” because I refuse to maul through a dying relatives valuables like a vulture.

I’ve invited them both to go to therapy. I’ve begged. I’ve pleaded. I’ve offered to pay. I’ve offered to find someone, pay the plane ticket and go.

“Let’s work this out. Name the time and place and I will go. I will pay. I will participate.” I’ve beseeched over and over again.

“I don’t want to do that with… YOU.” They repeat these exact words.

This is my greatest shame, my greatest pain.

My father is dead. My mother is insane and my siblings won’t speak to me. And my middle child heart is broken.

As I move forward in my life without my siblings, my mind tries to make sense of the loss. Recently, I remembered this event when I was about five years old.I was sitting reading a book when my oldest sister told me that my father was coming home. She told me that it was the last Friday of the month. She reminded me that our father had gifts for us last month, but forgot to give them to us. She asked me if I would ask our father if he brought us a gift.

“Dad likes you,” she said. “He won’t be angry.”

My oldest sister gets my other two sisters to join us and we line up at the door in expectation of our little $1, end of the month present.

Exhausted from the week and the 2 hour drive home, my father opened to door to our bright faces. In that moment, I’m certain he remembers that he’s forgotten the little gifts. (But I always make up stuff like that.)

I step forward and ask if he brought us our gifts. Shame shifted my father’s exhaustion to rage.

He beat me. Nothing new. Nothing different. Just another beating.

When it was over, my oldest sister told me that she was angry with me.

“If you never asked him, he wouldn’t have been angry,” she said. “You’ve ruined our chance at ever getting another gift.”

Because of what I “did”, my sisters didn’t speak to me for a week.

I’m beginning to wonder if not talking to my sisters is kind of a good thing. What do you think?

Bookmark and Share

No related posts.

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

  • http://lonegreysquirrel.blogspot.com lone grey squirrel

    I am sorry to hear about your relationship problems with your sisters. I wish sincerely that you will all find some way to overcome this. I know that it isn’t always the case but family can be one of the greatest blessings in this life. Problem is very often we need to face losing something before we learn how important it is to us. Again, I wish you healing and love.

  • http://TheWalkingMan TWM

    My sibling pecking order is fourth of five. I was not a sports player watcher or trier. Things both my brothers and long deceased father loved. I was not his gifted child as the other four were, a good mark for me was C+. The old pops really had genius level intelligence but it didn’t translate well and drove me off at 17, the soonest I could possibly get out.

    Two years ago the sibling information highway ended when my mom died. A couple of them tried, with me, to keep it open, a birthday card (first ever) a note at Christmas (first ever) but I do believe that the four of them know that I am not close with them and when I have something to say I will contact them and say it.

    It, sadly I admit, with me, is the same with my children, they are now adults I stayed close as I could after the divorce, called every week for 20 years, never missed a birthday or Christmas present yet was never invited to any function, like say their baptism or first communion or birthday party. We like my siblings are ok with each other on the planet and occasionally our paths will cross but the days of permanent connection beyond blood are gone Claudia. *Shrug* I am 53 and to old to worry about family.

    I walk with that One who created all, my wife and I are in love, and she dotes on the baby (the dog that killed the bear)

    It is enough. I am cordial but not family with these folks, my family live under bridges, fought in wars and lost a piece of themselves in a far away land. My family is mostly a different race than I but we get along and thrive daily. My family is sick and hungry. My family has found a way to accept what is their lot.

    So posh to them that say you can not pick your family, the only thing you can not do is change your past…that is the only thing you can not do, change your past.

    Peace

    TWM

  • http://pointless-drivel.com Mr. Fabulous

    I’ll be your sister.

  • http://odatmumbles.blogspot.com odat

    My heart goes out to you Claudia…..Do what feels right in your heart….and if that means cutting things off, then so be it…..I had to do that with my brother……I did everything I could to help him and in the end all I did was enable him in his behavior…..
    I wish you peace.

  • Jill

    Aww Claudia…

    Some people break up with their friends and boyfriends. Some people, a lot more than you know, break up with their family. It seems to me they cause more heartache, more pain than good. It may just be time to let them go. ((hug)) You’ll make the right decision.

  • http://www.shebecameabutterfly.net she

    Claudia, you are an inspiration to me every day. You are wise, hopeful, healthy, and loving. You have worked on your own healing and reach out to others like me. Never doubt any of that about yourself.

    It’s hard, I know, to get past the fact that it is they who do indeed have the problem. They are your flesh and blood. They are part of you. That doesn’t mean that they are all of you.

    If they will not accept help, they are going to live unhappy unhealthy lives — but you don’t need to be a part of that. You just keep being you the best way you know how. That’s what’s important.

    Besides, you have many other brothers and sisters in your life that you choose to have there and that have, in turn, chosen you.

  • http://on-a-limb.com Open Grove Claudia

    Squirrelly – I agree with you and have worked, struggled, begged and pleaded just to have some connection. I’ve accepted what little might be “given”, apologized, listened and I’ve loved. But now there’s nothing I can do. That’s why it hurts so much. Sometimes I think God wants me to learn something from this – I’m just not sure what.

    TWM – Thank you for sharing your experience. I too have a vast family of “ne’er-do-wells” and “hanger ons”. You inspire me to look at things differently.

    Fabbie – Thanks, man. We can be twins.

    Odat – I guess that’s true here too. The more I try, the more I enable them. You are a wise woman.

    Jill – It’s funny because this is my big secret. Maybe, like all secrets, it’s not such a big deal.

    She – Even the idea that “we” have a problem is foreign. It’s always just been me. You’ve got me thinking….

  • http://www.scrink.com Christy

    I wish I could take the bruises on your heart away. It’s odd how things creep up on you and then knock the wind out of you. I’m very sorry you are feeling blue. All I can say is I truly think you are a doll and I heart you bunches!

  • http://furiousball.com/inmydiatribe/ furiousball

    oh man, that stinks. my little sis and i get along great. i hope you all get this worked out before life lays a reminder of why grudges are so foolish.

  • http://www.fondofsnape.com Janet

    I agree with you about secrets, Claudia. I’m glad you got this out. My brother and I are not close, and I suspect when Dad passes, so will our relationship. So be it.

  • http://claudiasskippingstones.blogspot.com claudia

    It sounds to me like you’ve always been their scapegoat for whatever they need-and the more you try to fit in and be accepted, the more they reject you?? Time to change the cycle, no? Walk away…they seem to have made it very clear they don’t want you around, so, OK…done. It’s time to take care of yourself and just because they are family, it doesn’t give them the right to continue abusing you.

  • http://on-a-limb.com Open Grove Claudia

    Christy – It is weird how heart bruises creep up. Too bad too.

    FuriousBall – I so agree with you that grudges are foolish. I just can’t be the only one. I am very sad about it.

    Janet – That’s pretty much what happened when my Dad died. I am sorry.

    Claudia – Yes, they have been clear they don’t want me around. I’m certain you are right. Your succinct formulation is very helpful to me!

  • http://ledemeon.wordpress.com Michelle

    Sibling relationships can be so complicated. Hurt feelings, resentment, abandonment, I’ve felt them too. Sometimes a little space is what’s best. I’m counting on that to be true.

  • http://tuesdayupdate.blogspot.com/ tommie

    Claudia- While I am so sorry the hurt you must be going through, i totally understand. When a relationship is toxic, you can only make the decision that is best for you.

  • http://vixensden.com Vixen

    Well everyone really said it all so far. I understand your pain, but I don’t want you to feel shame. The shame is theirs, not yours. You made the effort and you put yourself out there. That is all you can do. You can’t change them. Because of your pain and sadness, and possibly your sense of missing something other’s have you tried. And that is all you can do. Now you need to do what makes you feel good, whatever that path is.

    God bless.

  • http://mayfairplace.blogspot.com awareness

    I just picked up an old book on the weekend I had read years ago by John Bradshaw….Healing the Shame that Binds You. It’s so interesting how a book that was purchased years ago resonated in a completely different way with me because I was reading with with new eyes and a new perspective…..and after some hard won life lessons. His book was one of the first that dealt specifically with shame…….both the healthy, humbling kind and the toxic stuff which often festers in families. You may find it an interesting read too Claudia.

    Most human beings refuse to look at their own shame producing behaviour. It’s too painful….easier to stay within the bubble of denial than admit and apologize. I’m wondering if this is one of the reasons why you get a flat refusal from your sisters…….? Their anger and rage is completely displaced isn’t it?

    Take care of yourself………..I find you a breath of fresh air full of life and love and kindness…… the shame you’re harbouring is what needs to be shed and you can do that while you choose the people in your life who will be your unconditional love and belonging family.

    Take care of your own wings and your own heart.

  • http://guiltywithanexplanation heart in san francisco

    Claudia, your sisters sound unbalanced and quite poisonous, while you are all about love and kindness and sharing and doing good. If they didn’t happen to be related to you, there is no way these people would be in your life.

    You have done more than enough to try to heal things, but that cannot ever be accomplished by only one person. Perhaps it is time to take all that wonderful energy and give it to those who truly love and appreciate you, and most of all, to yourself.

    You have never earned such abuse and do not deserve it. Let those unhappy women find another person to dump their anger and frustration on. Maybe you are being protected from further pain by their absence in your life.

    People sense energy shifts and like magnets which repel or attract, they will know on some level that Claudia has left the building. When you have truly removed your energy from them, they may even come back to you – on your terms.

    Sending hugs and blessings.

  • http://www.moobz.com Moobs

    I think the key to reconciliation, like comedy, is timing. Until the time is right it is wrong which means more pain and deeper wounds if you try and force it. It does not sound like the time is right.

    I’m with Mr F: if you need family – I’ll volunteer

  • http://www.miss-britt.com Miss Britt

    Ouch. I’m sorry. It doesn’t matter what causes the rift, it hurts just the same.

  • http://westofmars.blogspot.com Susan Helene Gottfried

    Yes. You are better off without them.

    I, too, would be glad to have you as my family. Bees and all.

  • http://fortresslinna.blogspot.com Dr. John

    You need to love them and forgive them and after that the problem is theirs not yours. Children raised in an abusive home often end up having trouble relating to each other. But you can’t change them. Yiu can only change you.

  • http://www.junecleavernirvana.blogspot.com HRH

    So sorry. My heart hurts for you and such a sad story. I wish it were different.

  • http://on-a-limb.com Open Grove Claudia

    Michelle – Good luck with your siblings – ‘cuz I’ll definitely need it with mine! ;)

    Tommie – Toxic? Huh, yes, I guess it is.

    Vixen – It’s hard to imagine them being ashamed. They are always so… right.

    Awareness – I love that book – I should read it again. Thanks for the suggestion. Yes, my wings, my heart. Good plan.

    Heart in SF – I honestly doubt they would notice if my energy shifted. They are a bit entranced in their own life and convinced of their illusions. I don’t exist.

    Moobzy – Hey, I thought you were already my older brother. ;) I think that’s a point well taken. Maybe the timings wrong.

    Miss Britt – Never ending rifts suck. and yes, they hurt.

    Susan Helene Gottfried – I’m certain you’re right. Yes, let’s form our own family.

    Dr. John – Yes, I need to give up changing them. Changing me is hard enough.

    HRH – I wish it were different too.

  • http://lbquijano.blogspot.com CQ

    This post brought me to tears. And I think of all the people who blame their crappy lives on their childhood or family or something else but you’re one of the best examples that you can use negative experiences and use them to make a good life. A better life than what you had when you were younger. You’re an inspiration. I still hope that there’d be some way for you to reconcile with your sisters though.

  • http://www.deboradennis.com Debora

    Oh Claudia, I’m so sorry. I feel your pain, as I have a very hot/cold relationship with my sister. After years of trying to be the “peacemaker” to her selfish antics, I’ve decided life is just too damn short to spend it someone that gets under skin they way she does.

    I hope you can either work it out or find the peace inside to live without them.

  • http://on-a-limb.com Open Grove Claudia

    CQ – I hope so too.

    Debora – I think, at this point, working it out is impossible. So peace it must be.

  • http://badkelly.wordpress.com kelly

    I let go of my father a long time ago. Just because they are family, doesn’t make them good for you. It took me a long time to stop feeling bad for myself, stop trying to make it better, and stop trying to change him in order to make our relationship better. Once I realized that I could do nothing to change him, therefore our relationship could never be more than unhealthy; I realized that the only thing I could do was change how I saw our relationship. Some say I lost hope, but really I just stopped making myself feel responsible for something I couldn’t control. I couldn’t control the way he treated me, or made me feel. I couldn’t control the fact that he didn’t want to be there for me, or be more of a part of my life. I just let go.

    Sometimes I feel bad that I don’t have a good relationship with that side of the family, but I am much better for it! I don’t have to have that in my life. Even if we share blood. Blood doesn’t mean they get the right to treat you poorly, forever.

    I have learned that it’s ok to let go.

    I love you! :-) You aren’t alone in the bad family department… :-) And I’m sorry you had to go through all of that.

  • http://julia-mindovermatter.blogspot.com/index.html julia

    After point-blank asking them to go to therapy and having them decline (which I’ve done with my own sister, who also declined every time) – the work for you now is in accepting how they actually are and not how you wish-with-all-your-heart they were.

    I actually saw a therapist for the express purpose of learning how to deal – or not deal – with my sister. After learning how to stand down, as it were, our relationship has really, really improved. Merely because I’ve stopped expecting that I can watch the horse that I’ve led to water stoop her neck and have a drink.

    And no matter how many times I gave many people the same advice, it only really sunk in when I worked it out with my therapist. Wacky but true.

    Obviously you know better than most people that your sisters share the same genetic make-up as your mother who is insane, and a father who flew into violent rages. They have mental health limitations that are bigger than you. So to preserve your own hard-won mental health, draw a BIG line and maintain your perimeter. If you swin out to a drowning person, she will only drag you under with her.

    And here’s a hug – (((hug)))

  • http://anticsofacrazymom.typepad.com nikki

    Sometimes as much as it hurts it best to separate yourself and do whats best for YOU.

  • http://on-a-limb.com Open Grove Claudia

    Kelly – I’ve done that as well with my sisters. Sadly, what they want is everything – there’s no way to engage without losing everything. They have no friends, no real connections, just parasitic need. I can only feel sorry for them. I am sorry about your dad. How awful.

    Julia – That’s excellent. I will tell you. Every therapist I have ever seen has told me to divorce my family. Every single one. Maybe I should listen to all the advice I pay for! ;) It seems to work for you!

    Nikki – I’m certain you are right – but hard to do.

  • jameil

    for now it probably is. my sister and i are likely too close in age. that means when we’re in the same house for more than 2 days (and sometimes even less) she starts thinking i’m trying to run her life and gets all pissy. you ask my advice or pour your heart out to me and want me to NOT tell you how to get people to stop running over you. either way you get mad at ME. whatever. stop telling me stuff and stop talking to me if that’s how it’s going to be. of course i would prefer for it not to be that way but i can’t keep being berated for being myself. i know you understand. it’s hard to explain to people who don’t have sisters.

  • http://on-a-limb.com Open Grove Claudia

    Jameil – Yes, I understand exactly.

  • CEO

    Dear Sister,

    I am divorced from my family. You already know that I actually care about what happens to you. The door is always open, and your room is ready for you and D.

    Love, your brother,

    Monty

  • http://eastcoastdweller.blogspot.com ECD

    Your sisters are obviously living exactly the way they learned from him: Manipulate, then blame and punish. The classic tool kit of the abuser.

    I am so sorry that You are on the receiving end of this. Know this, that NONE of this is Your fault.

blog comments powered by Disqus